Welp. This is the kind of question that requires me to write a long and complex sociopolitical/critical/historical/Discourse-esque analysis that will take a while and which I am trying to do only selectively, but I’m at home on Saturday morning, I don’t have anything else to do right now, and it does present me an opportunity to address some things I’ve been thinking about. So. We’ll give it a shot.
The first thing that has struck me is that in a few short weeks, we’re getting a sharp empirical disproving of two common online-leftist fallacies: one, the old “both parties are exactly the same” chestnut, and two, “the only resistance that matters is Violent Glorious Revolution” (which somehow and conveniently never happens). We had months and months of “Biden is just as bad as Trump!!!” being spread as gospel truth in online-leftist circles, and then when Harris took over, it switched just as seamlessly into “Harris is just as bad as [or even worse than] Trump!” Now, as I have said before, there were plenty of legitimate criticisms to make of Biden, particularly the Gaza policy (upon which Harris notably differed). But it’s quite telling that the keyboard warriors who spent all of last year howling for The Righteous Punishment of Biden-Harris (regardless that the obvious ancillary consequence was letting Trump come to power) have either disappeared completely when it comes to dealing with the results of that rhetoric, or have switched to “everything is doomed so I guess we shouldn’t bother anyway.” Like. Trump is now proposing to fully ethnically cleanse Gaza and either blithely hand it over to Israel or build Jared Kushner Beachfront Resort Disneyworld, and what do we hear in protest? For the most part, crickets. These are not serious people. Their opposition is not morally consistent, and it only depends on how they can make themselves look good. I thought that Trump was somehow supposed to be magically better than Biden particularly on the Gaza issue, and that was why it was worth letting him get elected? Or something? Something!?!
I’m curious as to whether those people still legitimately think that Harris would have spent her first few weeks in office dismantling USAID, signing weekly anti-trans executive orders, unleashing ICE across the country and terrorizing immigrant communities, putting the Project 2025 guy in charge of the Office of Management and Budget, letting Elon Musk run rampant with Treasury data, nominating the likes of RFK Jr. and Tulsi Gabbard to Cabinet posts, trying to freeze all federal funding, stripping DEI initiatives, dismantle the Department of Education – etc. etc. The thing is, as ghoulish as it is, none of this is a surprise, because it is literally what Trump and his people spent the entire presidential campaign loudly, openly, and repeatedly promising to do. However awful they were and are, they were not remotely secret about their intentions. That information was out in the open every time they opened their mouths. But too many people didn’t pay attention, rationalized it away, decided that “he won’t actually do that” (despite the fact that he launched a literal violent coup attempt on the Capitol the last time he was in office), or just made up their minds that Trump Will Reduce Grocery Prices and refused to listen to any information that countered that view. What do we get now? Trump laughing off the grocery-prices issue and insisting that it’s “not a priority” and Musk managing to claim that the real problem is government spending, not corporate greed. Again, this was completely predictable, because y’all got willingly suckered. It was not hard to see it coming.
That said: if the Glorious Online Leftist Revolution is still coming, and by some lights we might now legitimately need it, where the fuck is it? Are they still out there banging the drum against Trump and his “let’s ethnically cleanse Gaza” policy and anything else that they insisted, they swore up and down, was functionally equivalent or possibly even marginally better than Biden-Harris getting another term? No. They’re either dead silent, offering weak excuses, or completely giving into “we’re doomed there’s no point fighting back through weak shitlib institutions that are obviously terrible and will fail” blubbering that makes no fucking sense. One, because they move the goalposts so constantly that there’s not even any attempt to reckon with the last effects of their damaging bullshit, and two? As I said, where’s the fucking Revolution magically coming to save us and install a perfect leftist utopia (which is never how revolutions have ever worked) and sweep away Government Tyranny? Is that only for when a Democrat is in office and you can have confidence that the government is not going to come after you in the middle of the night for talking about it? Now that there’s an actual fascist in power, it’s somehow too hard to resist at all, even in small, institutional, and everyday ways that are often far more effective at practically confounding the bad stuff instead of empty and useless online echo chambers, so guess we should all just give up??!
Fuck. That.
This is also why we have to talk about the catastrophic lack of information literacy and critical thinking skills in young leftist spaces. A good example is the recent migration of TikTok users to the Chinese app RedNote. It was sweet for a little while as there was cultural exchange and friendship and memes. But then, predictably, it dove hard into “ah, once again The Evil US Government Has Lied To Us and there are no problems at all in China!” I have seen posts float by on my dash that unironically claim this is the case and China is truly great and Americans should want to move there and clearly all that business about authoritarian control and mass repression was just a ruse by, again, The Evil US Government. If you are so utterly devoid of basic information literacy and research abilities that your standard of proof for “is the Chinese government repressively authoritarian and totalitarian” is “a random Chinese person on an app in a country where the Internet is viciously controlled and voicing the slightest criticism can make you disappear told me that it isn’t,” then for Christ’s fucking sake, you need help. For one, it wasn’t just the US government saying this. It was, y’know, Chinese dissidents, the entire nation of Taiwan, historians, academics, researchers, the Uyghur Muslims of Xinjiang, etc etc. If your only standard for believing or supporting anything is “the opposite of what the US government thinks,” then you are perfect targets for authoritarianism. Hey, a person living under an authoritarian regime who will punish them if they speak out against it told me everything was fine! Clearly there’s nothing to worry about and we should want it here in America!
Come on. Come on.
This is also the case because uneducated young leftists like to unironically label themselves “communists” or “Marxist-Leninists” as if it’s cool and hip and has never been involved in anything problematic in all of history, so anything that calls itself that must be supported. Shoutout to the idiot in my notes recently who reblogged a several-year-old post just to shout at me about how historical communists NEVER worked with or collaborated with fascists, because something something The Communists Were The Pure Shining Good Guys! (Uh, nobody tell them about the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact.) Clearly, the Chinese Communist Party is good and beneficial, end of story, no more criticism or caution needed! Obviously, yes, official American policy toward China has often been driven by basic Sinophobia, and the determination that nobody can change American hegemony or unipolarity or its ability to call the shots how it pleases. But if that is the literally only criteria you’re using, then yeah. If you’re so unaware that “the Chinese people are ordinary human beings” and “the Chinese government is repressive and authoritarian” are statements that can and in fact do coexist, then apparently you’ve missed the situation you’re in right now, where “the American people are ordinary human beings” and “the American government is repressive and authoritarian” is also the case. Because online leftism is essentially devoid of a consistent moral principle and will just blithely switch up to support Bad Things as long as they’re being done by governments with the correct ideological label, here we are.
Anyway. This is getting long, but the main takeaway is that the “all resistance against Trump is doomed and I guess we just gotta die :(” line is now, somehow, often coming from the same people who were constantly yelling that the only hope was a Glorious Revolution against Biden-Harris, and it is somehow even stupider. So you’ll trumpet about Gloriously Overthrowing The Government all the day long as long as a Democrat is in office, but the instant a Republican gets in there instead and starts acting like an actual fascist, welp, time to just shut up and accept our doom and not even bother to struggle? Please tell me how any of that makes sense. Especially when actively confounding the Trump/Musk Axis of Evil is already working. There is also the fact that the establishment-media types are supporting this narrative for reasons of their own; witness the fact that the entire US corporate media is owned by oligarchs who hastened to bend the knee and pledge fealty to Trump 2.0. They obviously also have a reason for inculcating hopelessness in you, and that the only recourse is to shut up, accept it, and let them continue to rob you blind. Because American democracy will never matter as much as money, power, and control for the Billionaire Bros.
The point is: this is a bad-faith narrative on all sides. Whether it’s coming from the online leftists in their latest head-spinningly hypocritical volte-face, the oligarch-owned corporate media that wants to feed you constant Bad News to keep you clicking and worried and distracted and unable to resist, the Trumpist power that wants people to quit making this pesky stink about all their authoritarian fascist adventures, or anyone else. There is nobody who has your best interests at heart if they are telling you that everything is doomed and the only thing to do is lie down and take it. There is no logical reason you should listen to them. Go forth and keep resisting, in whatever way presents itself. Those cumulative small actions are far more effective than any Splendid Revolution that never, ever materializes, while the people who preach it just sit back and whine about how things are so bad now so clearly they couldn’t. Shut up.
It is always important. It always matters. It will make a difference.
i don’t respect DNIs not in the sense i go out of my way to break them but in the sense that i don’t respect DNIs as a concept and consider them to be something of a red flag in general.
i’m not sure how to explain it but it’s the combination of usually putting very serious issues on the same level as fandom stuff, the fact that half the time people don’t even know what they’re against beyond ‘the bad stuff’ therefore even further watering these issues down, and the idea that other people are expected to manage your online existence for you.
there’s a passiveness to it that i think is actually a problem and it does not surprise me in the slightest that people with DNIs tend to view what media they consume as activism. do you get what i’m saying.
The DNI mindset of “curating my experience is everybody else’s problem, not mine; it’s not my job to avoid or block things that upset me but their job to take care to never interact with me in the first place” is certainly not a great mindset to start from.
if pointing out that the age of getting a phone decreasing along with the prevalence of short form video as the dominant form of social media content during the most significant collective educational gap in recent history all of which happened during one of the most significant windows of psychological development in a human lifetime has had a deleterious effect on the attention spans, self-regulation, impulse control, social skills, tech literacy, and actual literacy of zoomers and gen alpha. if pointing out that that is a real and serious problem makes me a boomer and an old crank who has fallen for “kids these days” propaganda someone find me a porch and a rocking chair so i can yell at you to get off my lawn
it really is all of us or bust btw. we cannot accept conditional acceptance of queer people, we cannot accept the exclusion of some in exchange for inclusion of others, it’s all of us or nothing and we have to be so fucking clear about that. don’t let conservatives or terfs or twitter discourse convince you that there’s any other option. don’t let them get away with it. we’re all going to fucking make it and we’re not leaving anybody behind
amhrancas 